What A 1950s Texas Textbook Can Teach Us About Today’s Textbook Fight

On the Mexican-American history textbook:

“One of the fundamental problems with the scholarship of the book is that you have non-historians writing a textbook for history,” said Trinidad Gonzales, a professor of history at South Texas College. “It’s really a polemic masquerading as a textbook, and it’s really trying to argue that Mexican-American culture, including Catholicism, is a fundamental threat to American democracy.”

On seventh-grade Texas history textbook, published in 1954:

“What you have set up here is this mythology. The women who helped these brave men were wives and mothers. They were connected to men through marriage and motherhood. They were not single women. They were not working women. They were not reformers,” [Dr. Nancy Baker Jones of the Ruth Winegarden Foundation for Texas Women’s History] said. “They were the women that were in their socially approved places to the exclusion of many other roles that women have played and contributions that women have made and lives that women have lived.”

This textbook was used by public school students across Texas in the late 1950s and early 1960s, so it helped shape the perceptions and attitudes of people who today would likely be in their ‘60s.

…The textbook acknowledges that slavery at least played a role in the Civil War, but it also treats African-Americans as sub-humans, and again, only defines their history in terms of the convenience of slavery to Anglo, white property owners.

…”That was not just the reigning consensus in a middle school Texas history textbook. That was the reigning consensus in the 1950s in the northern and mid-western dominated college history professoriate. That’s the way college history was written about.” [Benjamin Johnson, an associate professor of history at Loyola University in Chicago]

[Walter Buenger, a professor in the history department at Texas A&M University] agrees. He says academics taught a whole generation to think of African-Americans as “children who were easily misled” after the end of slavery, which he says translates into modern day racism.

What A 1950s Texas Textbook Can Teach Us About Today’s Textbook Fight – Houston Public Media

hmmmm

Hundreds Of Trump Supporters Are Angrily Tweeting A Canadian Theatre Company In Hamilton, Ontario

Hundreds of angry, and deeply confused Trump supporters, unleashed a vicious Twitter tirade against the Hamilton Theatre Inc., located in Hamilton, Ontario

…“They’ve been calling to boycott Hamilton and stage protests but little do they know that they are picking on Hamilton, Ontario’s oldest musical theatre company,” [Riane Leonard, a member of the theatre company’s production team] said.

“None of them have bothered to actually look at our account to see that they are wrong.”

…“You’re funneling it to the wrong person, guys,” she said. “All you need to do is check our profile to see we’re not even in the same country.”

But she’s glad if the mix-up resulted in a few less vitriolic tweets sent to the Hamilton cast.

“If we helped take any of the heat off our friends on Broadway, we’re here to help.”

Hundreds Of Trump Supporters Are Angrily Tweeting A Canadian Theatre Company In Hamilton, Ontario|The Gaily Grind

Heh

State Board of Education Rejects Mexican-American Studies Textbook

After months of protests from historians, teachers and lawmakers, the Texas State Board of Education this morning unanimously rejected a controversial 

Mexican-American studies textbook that would have been used in public schools.

About a dozen professors across Texas found hundreds of factual errors in the textbook. Many were also upset that the book, titled “Mexican-American Heritage,” promoted stereotypes of groups of people.

The book called Mexican people lazy and said Chicanos wanted to destroy society. 

State Board of Education Rejects Mexican-American Studies Textbook | KUT

hmmm

Texas and Textbooks

Texas and Textbooks | The Huffington Post

Sigh…

Some background history:

Conservative members of the Texas Board of Education don’t want to create a group of state university professors to fact-check students’ textbooks for potential errors, despite recent controversies…

Source: Texas Board of Education Refuses To Allow Professors To Fact-Check Textbooks

~~~

A broken process at the Texas State Board of Education has allowed right-wing activists to politicize the facts—or fiction—that get taught in history class.

Source: Was Moses a Founding Father? – The Atlantic

~~~

Moses and the American Constitution: If Texas wants biblical characters and states’ rights in textbooks, publishers are happy to deliver.

Source: Texas board of education hearings: Moses and states’ rights in social studies textbooks.

~~~

No matter where you live, if your children go to public schools, the textbooks they use were very possibly written under Texas influence. If they graduated with a reflexive suspicion of the concept of separation of church and state and an unexpected interest in the contributions of the National Rifle Association to American history, you know who to blame.

…Texas originally acquired its power over the nation’s textbook supply because it paid 100 percent of the cost of all public school textbooks, as long as the books in question came from a very short list of board-approved options.

…The books on the Texas list were likely to be mass-produced by the publisher in anticipation of those sales, so other states liked to buy them and take advantage of the economies of scale.

…All the bickering and pressuring over the years has caused publishers to shy away from using the kind of clear, lively language that might raise hackles in one corner or another. The more writers were constrained by confusing demands and conflicting requests, the more they produced unreadable mush.  ..The [Thomas B. Fordham Institute evaluation of US history standards for public schools authors] said,

“the document distorts or suppresses less triumphal or more nuanced aspects of our past that the Board found politically unacceptable (slavery and segregation are all but ignored, while religious influences are grossly exaggerated). The resulting fusion is a confusing, unteachable hodgepodge.”

All around the country, teachers and students are left to make their way through murky generalities as they struggle through the swamps of boxes and lists. “Maybe the most striking thing about current history textbooks is that they have lost a controlling narrative,” wrote historian Russell Shorto.

And that’s the legacy. Texas certainly didn’t single-handedly mess up American textbooks, but its size, its purchasing heft, and the pickiness of the school board’s endless demands—not to mention the board’s overall craziness—certainly made it the trend leader. Texas has never managed to get evolution out of American science textbooks. It’s been far more successful in helping to make evolution—and history, and everything else—seem boring.

Source: How Texas Inflicts Bad Textbooks on Us | by Gail Collins | The New York Review of Books

#BoycottHamilton: Reaction to Trump Supporters’ Movement 

Celebrities jumped to weigh in after Donald Trump and Mike Pence supporters called for a boycott of the Broadway musical “Hamilton”

You know what? I support #BoycottHamilton. I hope it intensifies — especially during the first week of March, maybe that Sunday matinee?

#BoycottHamilton: Celebrities React to Trump Supporters’ Movement | Variety

heh

British woman arrested in Dubai after reporting rape, group says 

A British tourist has been arrested in Dubai on charges of extramarital sex after telling police she was raped by a group of British nationals while in the United Arab Emirates, according to a UK-based legal advice group called Detained in Dubai.

British woman arrested in Dubai after reporting rape, group says – CNN.com

Despite the glittery PR campaigns Dubai always sounds like a total shithole whenever it pops up in the news. What the heck do these silly tourists and ex-pats expect? The laws are in the stone ages.

Why misogyny won 

In the context of Trump, a benevolent sexist might hear the “grab ’em by the pussy” tape and say that he’s horrified because he has a daughter — which suggests that his first instinct is to paternalistically shield his female relatives from harm, rather than to see sexual assault as an objective moral horror no matter who you’re related to.

Meanwhile, a hostile sexist would claim the benevolent sexist is overreacting — that the tape doesn’t actually describe sexual assault, just normal male sexual aggression.

These attitudes might seem diametrically opposed to one another. But they’re actually two sides of the same coin, Peter Glick, professor of psychology and social sciences at Lawrence University, told Vox. People can hold both of these sexist views at the same time, and they very often do.

“It’s how men can wear ‘Trump That Bitch’ T-shirts at a Trump rally, and then go home and say, ‘I love my wife and daughter,’” Glick said.

Trump expresses both hostile and benevolent attitudes toward women all the time. When he likes a woman, he praises her in a patronizing way (usually focusing on her physical beauty). When he doesn’t, he viciously insults her.

Benevolent sexism is the carrot, Glick explained, and hostile sexism is the stick. If you’re a “good” woman who meets expected gender norms — who has warm feminine charms, who maintains strict beauty standards, whose ambitions are focused on home and hearth — you will be rewarded with affection, protection, and praise. But step outside those norms, and you risk being labeled as one of the “bad” girls who are abused and scorned only because they deserve it.

It’s a tidy little cycle. Benevolent sexism is supposed to protect women from hostile sexism, and hostile sexism is supposed to keep women in line with the ideals of benevolent sexism.

But while benevolent sexism may put women on a pedestal, Glick said, it’s a very narrow pedestal that’s easy to fall off of. This is the whole reason that our age-old “Madonna versus whore” dichotomy exists in the first place: If women can be separated into good girls and bad, and only bad girls get punished, it justifies male dominance and absolves men of blame for treating women unfairly.

And it’s why Trump, despite the long list of sexist words and deeds to his name, can insist that “nobody respects women more” than he does — and why some people, including women, actually believe him.

…The basic agreement is that as long as women cater to men’s needs, men will protect and cherish women in return.

…Sexual assault is the ultimate expression of hostile sexism. But the protection racket of benevolent sexism gives women a lot of incentive to either forgive men for it, or blame women.

The alternative — acknowledging that the system is broken, and that virtue can’t protect you from violence — can be too terrible to contemplate.

Why misogyny won – Vox

hmmm

This isn’t just a photo of Ivanka Trump. It’s a middle finger to democracy.

Instead of liquidating his assets and placing them in a Qualified Diversified Trust, as President Bush did, or investing in index funds and government bonds, as President Obama did, Trump has done nothing.

He’s waved away concerns about conflicts-of-interest, saying that he would just hand over control of his business interests to his children.

…Immediately after Trump’s election, he named three of his adult children — Ivanka, Eric, and Donald Jr. — to his transition team. This means the same people running the Trump Organization will also be choosing the top officials in the Trump administration.

…In his first meeting with an head of state, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, Trump invited his daughter Ivanka — who will likely serve as acting CEO of his companies — to participate.

…Nepotism laws prohibit Ivanka from taking a formal role in the White House. But Trump is choosing to send a clear signal to Japan and the world — when you deal with Ivanka, you are dealing with someone who has my ear as president.

This isn’t just a photo of Ivanka Trump. It’s a middle finger to democracy.

hmmm

This woman has been stuck in Korea for three years trying to get home to the US 

Her adoptive parents never filed the paperwork to make her a US citizen. So Kim Craig fell through the cracks. And now she finds herself stuck in Korea after a visit, unable to get back to the US. 

This woman has been stuck in Korea for three years trying to get home to the US | Public Radio International

WTF?! Citizenship needs to be retroactively given to all adoptees of American citizens. Yesterday.

Jon Stewart Asks Donald Trump ‘What Makes Amerca Great?’  

“One of the things that I think struck me as odd about this election was…nobody asked Donald Trump what makes America great.” Being that Trump’s central theme was returning America to this mythical time of unsurpassed greatness, it would have been helpful if Trump illustrated what he really means.

Jon Stewart Asks Donald Trump ‘What Makes Amerca Great?’  | GOOD

hmmm

Donald Trump Demands Apology After Comments From ‘Hamilton’ Cast 

Also on Twitter Saturday morning, Mr. Trump weighed in on all the buzz about Vice President-elect Mike Pence’s attendance at the musical “Hamilton” in New York on Friday evening. Mr. Pence arrived at the famous production but was greeted with boos, and the cast addressed him after the performance from the stage.

 Mr. Trump blasted the actors, saying Mr. Pence “was harrassed last night at the theater by the cast of Hamilton, cameras blazing. This should not happen!” A few minutes later, he demanded the Hamilton cast apologize to Mr. Pence: “The cast of Hamilton was very rude last night to a very good man, Mike Pence. Apologize!”

Source: Donald Trump Demands Apology After Comments From ‘Hamilton’ Cast, Also Tweets on Trump U. – Washington Wire – WSJ

Apparently in Trump’s America freedom of speech applies only to him.

LAPD will not help deport immigrants under Trump, chief says 

Los Angeles Police Chief Charlie Beck said Monday that he has no plans to change the LAPD ’s stance on immigration enforcement, despite President-elect Donald Trump ’s pledge to toughen federal immigration laws and deport millions of people upon taking office.

...“I don’t intend on doing anything different,” he said. “We are not going to engage in law enforcement activities solely based on somebody’s immigration status. We are not going to work in conjunction with Homeland Security on deportation efforts. That is not our job, nor will I make it our job.”

LAPD will not help deport immigrants under Trump, chief says – LA Times

hmmm

BREAKING: Trump Requests Security Clearances for His Children – Who Will Be Running His ‘Blind’ Trust 

Donald Trump’s attorney has gone on record saying the president-elect’s three adult children will be running all of Trump’s businesses in what Trump is calling a “blind trust,” even though, by definition, that is not a blind trust.

Late last week many analysts expressed concern over that arrangement, which was then compounded when it Trump announced that his three adult children …would be part of the Trump administration’s transition team. …responsible for hiring decisions of the estimated 4000 people that comprise the White House team, including 1000 who will require congressional approval. The transition team is also responsible for establishing policy initiatives and even strategy.

…NBC News reports that President-elect Trump has now “asked about” security clearances for his three children.

BREAKING: Trump Requests Security Clearances for His Children – Who Will Be Running His ‘Blind’ Trust – The New Civil Rights Movement

WTF?!